cphollis wrote: ↑20 Feb 2024, 14:47
Aftertouch on the NS4 is implemented with a pressure strip under the keybed, so it's unlikely a "software fix" is coming.
It is actually two strips, one for the black and one for the white keys.
cphollis wrote: ↑20 Feb 2024, 14:47
If the strip is firm as it is on the NS4, it takes some finger pressure to fire it off. So AT implementation will always be a tradeoff.
I find the NS4 AT implementation quite usable. However, I've got fiercely strong piano hands.
I also find the white keys usable, but as thread starter noted, black notes are just so stiff, that I fear I'm going to bend the keyboard. Especially when on chords, when your both arms pressure rest on more notes, say an F# chord, with full blacks, it is really hard to fire it off, and after firing it is uncontrollable, as someone already said, like an ON/OFF switch. Like you cannot just halfway open a filter with it in a controlled way. Even on one black key I need 3 justaposed fingers and the thumbs underneath the keyboard to be strong enough to control it in some way. It is just bad.
Nowhere near accidentally actuating it on the white keys either, but the black strip (on my unit) is just unusable. However I went in the store, where I bought it (it's an official vendor in Budapest), and the exposed unit in the store didn't have the issue. There was maybe some slight difference between blacks and whites, but still usable, nowhere that harsh a difference as my unit has.
It bothers me, because this renders one of the three MORPH (CtrlPed,Wheel, AT) unusable, and it is not just a side feature of the keyboard. Also for this kind of money it should work flawlessly (especially, as someone said, in a world with poly AT midi keyboards, wich are much cheaper).
I don't know if the fault is Clavias QC issue, or the keybed manufacturers (Fatar), maybe the latter, cos guess keybeds come assembled.
But the problem is there anyway, and it is annoyingly bad, and turns out it is even inconsistent between boards - which is pretty wild, since how could one buy one from an online store peacefully, if this part is lottery.
I'd like mine to be replaced, or serviced by the vendor. Have no clue how that can happen, maybe these strips are just different batches, who knows if there is a solution at all.
Will come back with news eventually.