Page 1 of 1

Nord+Rhodes piano...a LOT of noise!

Posted: 25 Apr 2022, 14:40
by pabloevaristo
I´ve seen a lot of posts about the transformers inside our Nords to be buzzing and noisy.
It´s not my case, my Electro5d makes absolutely no audible noise. But I have a problem when stacking it over my Rhodes...
There´s an incredible high induced noise in the Rhodes´ signal... it´s Impossible to use... :-(
I have to lift the nord more then 25-30cm to get rid of the humm. Tried to connect the Nord to different wallets..
Rhodes is super silent with the Retroflyer preamp installed and it´s great isolated.
I know aluminium is not effective, so there is any other solution around?
How could I shield the rhodes for the magnetic field of the nord does not interfiere?¿?¿?¿?


Thanks!!

Re: Nord+Rhodes piano...a LOT of noise!

Posted: 25 Apr 2022, 15:11
by Mr_-G-
Never tried this myself but I heard of people lining the inside of the Rhodes cover with metallic (sticky) tape and then connecting a cable from the metal lining to the ground of the audio signal. I also heard that placing a metal sheet between the rhodes and the top instrument helps (similar principle, trying to create a 'Faraday's cage').

Re: Nord+Rhodes piano...a LOT of noise!

Posted: 26 Apr 2022, 09:53
by pabloevaristo
Mr_-G- wrote:Never tried this myself but I heard of people lining the inside of the Rhodes cover with metallic (sticky) tape and then connecting a cable from the metal lining to the ground of the audio signal. I also heard that placing a metal sheet between the rhodes and the top instrument helps (similar principle, trying to create a 'Faraday's cage').
Yes but that depends on the metal you use for that... I tried aluminium, but it´s not working... Just trying to find someone that have found something that actually works...
Thanks for your response

Re: Nord+Rhodes piano...a LOT of noise!

Posted: 26 Apr 2022, 12:25
by FZiegler
I think you might even ask the Nord support - or your national distributor. Maybe they have an idea about that - that would be another type of support I'd appreciate: 'Any comments about using your product in my special environment???'

Re: Nord+Rhodes piano...a LOT of noise!

Posted: 26 Apr 2022, 13:15
by analogika
pabloevaristo wrote:
Mr_-G- wrote:Never tried this myself but I heard of people lining the inside of the Rhodes cover with metallic (sticky) tape and then connecting a cable from the metal lining to the ground of the audio signal. I also heard that placing a metal sheet between the rhodes and the top instrument helps (similar principle, trying to create a 'Faraday's cage').
Yes but that depends on the metal you use for that... I tried aluminium, but it´s not working... Just trying to find someone that have found something that actually works...
Thanks for your response
Aluminium should work fine. I used household aluminium foil to shield my Clavinet D6, and those things are notoriously hum-sensitive (like, "neighbour's electric toothbrush causes buzz" sensitive).
The foil needs to be grounded, though.

Re: Nord+Rhodes piano...a LOT of noise!

Posted: 26 Apr 2022, 13:42
by WannitBBBad
If shielding/grounding the top of the Rhodes doesn't completely eliminate the hum, a noise gate can work well at dropping the hum when not playing on the Rhodes. Good luck!

Re: Nord+Rhodes piano...a LOT of noise!

Posted: 26 Apr 2022, 16:15
by Mr_-G-
Maybe you need a thicker sheet? Thickness (as well as material) seem to make a difference. See graph in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faraday_cage

Re: Nord+Rhodes piano...a LOT of noise!

Posted: 26 Apr 2022, 16:56
by Rusty Mike
Way back when I owned a Rhodes (1976 Mark I Stage), I built my own custom flat top for it. I lined the inside of the top with a thin copper sheet and connected it to the chassis ground. It seemed to take care of the problem.

Re: Nord+Rhodes piano...a LOT of noise!

Posted: 26 Apr 2022, 17:16
by wtibbit
I'm an electrical engineer and have designed electromagnetic shielding systems for electronic circuits. I assume the hum is 60 cycle noise caused by a transformer - likely the power supply transformer - generating a magnetic field. If that is the case, electric field shielding using a a non-magnetic conductor such as aluminum or copper will not be effective, because those materials are typically used for RF electric field shielding. Instead, a material with high magnetic permeability is required, such as 3M 1380 sheet. A solution in that case could be adding magnetic shielding using 1380 around the problem transformer, which might be the power supply transformer.

There is a possibility that the issue IS caused by an electric field rather than a magnetic field, so you might try again with aluminum foil between the two instruments, this time being sure to ground the foil with a length of wire to a good ground on the piano. I would start with the metal body of the piano's output jack, because that is easy. If that works let me know and I'll suggest a way to install a permanent electric field shield inside the cover.

Personally I would just set the two keyboards up in an L-configuration.... ;)