Stage 3 88 vs Piano 5

[Snyper19]

this is so tempting... I think I've decided to go for Stage 3 , there lots of deals ... Guitar Center 48 monthly payment, Sweetwater 36 monthly payment. do they know something new is coming out or simply these are just good deals

[FZiegler]

Keep the Yamaha P515 - it's the better instrument to learn to play the piano! Or you definitely want to switch into pop music.

[Snyper19]

I wouldn’t mind playing those 80s 90s songs but we’ll see if I pull the plug.

[Winds]

I think most have said pretty much the same thing but if just based on those 2 choices you quoted, and you're more of a piano player, P5 is the way. (At least you'd save effectively about $2000 (?), the action on P5 is better than the NS3, and you wouldn't need to spend an extra 2k on features you probably won't use since you're more piano oriented.. just my 2 cents)

[Miguel2202]

So even though im very new to this world i might have a very interesting point here.

So i startad to play in march this year, with a casio ct-s1, and quickly realized it was crazy fun and i needed 88 keys for the classical, so i bought myself a piano 5 which was and still is an amazing instrument however
As a new player i find it really fun to imitate "cool" songs and it's a great way to have fun while learning,and the nord piano 5 is so capable when it comes to creating cool sounds that i realized how much more i could do and now i want a stage 3.

Now the stage 3 is old and the new format that the NP5 have is around the corner, but it doesnt make the stage 3 bad in any way, from what iv'e found, the stage 3 is an amazing tool.
I've been waiting the whole weekend for Nord to say anything about anything at the NAMM show but i've havent found anything so far. So i guess they wont release a stage 4 tomorrow atleast.

Even though the uncertainty i've decided to buy a stage 3 on thusday, the qustion is, do i keep my piano 5 or do i sell it, i know i can utilize the piano 5 via the stage so im uncertain at this point.
The thing is before i bought the NP5 a was choosing between the NS3 and the NP5, I choose the NP5 thinking it would be enough and i wanted the new format, an now i know i made the wrong choice.

It's kind of a bummer but im stoked to get my hands on a stage

*Edit* I might add, i thought i was mostly in to classical music and regular piano, until i got my hands on the PN5 and saw the possibilities

[Snyper19]

So even though im very new to this world i might have a very interesting point here.

So i startad to play in march this year, with a casio ct-s1, and quickly realized it was crazy fun and i needed 88 keys for the classical, so i bought myself a piano 5 which was and still is an amazing instrument however
As a new player i find it really fun to imitate "cool" songs and it's a great way to have fun while learning,and the nord piano 5 is so capable when it comes to creating cool sounds that i realized how much more i could do and now i want a stage 3.

Now the stage 3 is old and the new format that the NP5 have is around the corner, but it doesnt make the stage 3 bad in any way, from what iv'e found, the stage 3 is an amazing tool.
I've been waiting the whole weekend for Nord to say anything about anything at the NAMM show but i've havent found anything so far. So i guess they wont release a stage 4 tomorrow atleast.

Even though the uncertainty i've decided to buy a stage 3 on thusday, the qustion is, do i keep my piano 5 or do i sell it, i know i can utilize the piano 5 via the stage so im uncertain at this point.
The thing is before i bought the NP5 a was choosing between the NS3 and the NP5, I choose the NP5 thinking it would be enough and i wanted the new format, an now i know i made the wrong choice.

It's kind of a bummer but im stoked to get my hands on a stage

*Edit* I might add, i thought i was mostly in to classical music and regular piano, until i got my hands on the PN5 and saw the possibilities

Thanks for that Tocayo! I guess I’m in the same boat as you and by reading your post I think I will go for NS3 or maybe wIt a while … we’ll see

[WannitBBBad]

...Even though the uncertainty i've decided to buy a stage 3 on thusday, the qustion is, do i keep my piano 5 or do i sell it, i know i can utilize the piano 5 via the stage so im uncertain at this point...

Hello, the answer is "it depends" The Stage 3 Compact is a perfect companion to the Piano 5 if you plan on playing out or want to broaden your playing to more organ and synth with a semi-weighted keyboard action. With the Stage 3 you can also make organ/synth samples to play on your Piano 5 for an even better experience with the two. However, if you go that route, downsizing will be a hard decision as getting rid of the Piano 5 will leave you with a semi-weighted Stage 3. I still play out from time to time and get along just fine with my Stage 3 and no other keyboard, so if it was me, I would get a Stage 3 88 and would probably sell the Piano 5 while it's still a new keyboard. The good news is that Nords retain their value quite well, so if you can afford keep both, you have time to figure out if the Stage 3 88 alone will meet your musical needs. Good luck to you.

[Miguel2202]

...Even though the uncertainty i've decided to buy a stage 3 on thusday, the qustion is, do i keep my piano 5 or do i sell it, i know i can utilize the piano 5 via the stage so im uncertain at this point...

...I would get a Stage 3 88 and would probably sell the Piano 5 while it's still a new keyboard. The good news is that Nords retain their value quite well, so if you can afford keep both, you have time to figure out if the Stage 3 88 alone will meet your musical needs. Good luck to you.

Thanks, I'm buying the stage before I sell the piano even if I'm keeping it or not, but as you say regarding the key amount, I could buy a smaller one, but I'm not quite sure how it will work out in the end, the Compact as you say give me another option while the 88 key give me "security".

As of now im thinking 88 keys, but we will see.

[FZiegler]

The issue is probably not so much the number of keys, but the type of keybed. The Stage 3 Compact has an organ optimised, waterfall style keybed, while the Stage 3-HA88 is more into piano style with its weighted keybed.

[M1tsos]

Stage 3 isnt optimised for piano… you will start hear the piano sound without expressio. Without feel… the action is not so good like it is at the piano 5..

If you are targeting for piano playing keep the piano 5 or try nord grand..

Stage 3 is better as a synth-organ.. the pianos sound like they dont have many velocity steps .. i dont know if i used the correct english word for what i want to say… i hope you understand me..