Yamaha HS8 monitors or Line 6 112 PowerCab

taliesin · Post by **taliesin** » 29 Jan 2019, 03:28

These are pretty much my 2 options to go with for my stage 3. Any one have experience with these or a suggestion to go with?

Post by **DJKeys** » 29 Jan 2019, 03:33

The Line 6 is made for Guitar Modeler Amplification. I had a line 6 extension powered 12 and it sounded great for guitar, but it is unsuitable for keyboards in my opinion-

-dj

taliesin · Post by **taliesin** » 29 Jan 2019, 04:01

Good point thanks. Saw a few other threads with people saying the hs8s sound great.

Phun Tunes · Post by **Phun Tunes** » 29 Jan 2019, 04:06

taliesin wrote:These are pretty much my 2 options to go with for my stage 3. Any one have experience with these or a suggestion to go with?

Apples & Grapefruits.
I tried a PC with my Axe FX (guitar modeler as mentioned) and even in Flat mode it did not seem flat. I would also say not enough low-end bass if needed for keyboard. I have other FRFR cabs (Atomic CLR Neo & Matrix FR10 & FR12's) and the difference was obvious. It does have more of that guitar amp or even keyboard amp feel.
HS8 is more flat and probably more low-end but adjust on the back for the room. But they are near-field so placement is critical.

So the PC is more like a guitar amp/speaker. You can place them almost anywhere. And more for filling a room with sound.
The HS8 are monitors. Placement effects the sound. But they sound best within a short distance. Not for filling a room.

So the question is really do you need apples or grapefruits? Or pomegranates?

Post by **NoDirection** » 29 Jan 2019, 11:37

The Yamaha HS7 and 8 sound great for playing at home or in studio. I guess that is your intended use. For playing to an audience, there are much better options...

taliesin · Post by **taliesin** » 29 Jan 2019, 23:42

Went with the 8s

kirsty · Post by **kirsty** » 02 Feb 2019, 00:07

Have your 8's arrived as yet? If so what are your thoughts.

I have the HS7's, (pretty white ones

) and they sound fabulous

. Almost bought the 8's but got the 7's at a price too good to turn down and have been very impressed with their clarity.

JayDee · Post by **JayDee** » 02 Feb 2019, 07:20

I have a pair of HS 8's also. I only have KRK Rockit monitors to compare to, but IMHO they're better than those, much more flat, not so hyped. They're near field monitors, strictly for the studio.

kirsty · Post by **kirsty** » 02 Feb 2019, 12:37

Glad i went with the Yamahas then. I read a few review suggesting the KRK's werent all they were cracked up to be in comparison

fbachmann · Post by **fbachmann** » 02 Feb 2019, 13:52

After listening to some 7" and 8" studio monitors, I just got the Fluid Audio F5, sounds great despite its more discreet size:
https://www.fluidaudio.com/f5.html

YMMV
François

Nord User Forum

Yamaha HS8 monitors or Line 6 112 PowerCab

Yamaha HS8 monitors or Line 6 112 PowerCab

Re: Yamaha HS8 monitors or Line 6 112 PowerCab

Re: Yamaha HS8 monitors or Line 6 112 PowerCab

Re: Yamaha HS8 monitors or Line 6 112 PowerCab

Re: Yamaha HS8 monitors or Line 6 112 PowerCab

Re: Yamaha HS8 monitors or Line 6 112 PowerCab

Re: Yamaha HS8 monitors or Line 6 112 PowerCab

Re: Yamaha HS8 monitors or Line 6 112 PowerCab

Re: Yamaha HS8 monitors or Line 6 112 PowerCab

Re: Yamaha HS8 monitors or Line 6 112 PowerCab