Comments, suggestions, questions about this forum? Post it here! Also for test purposes or Off-Topic discussions.

Does a band’s lyricist typically write melodies as well?

Postby Jericho-79 » 06 Jul 2014, 21:14

I just discovered an underground band from my area that recently released an EP on indie record label. On that EP, I found something peculiar about the songwriting credits.

All the music is credited to the entire band, while all the lyrics AND all the melodies are credited to the band’s lead singer.

I thought that the creation of melodies (as well as harmonies, rhythms, riffs, and chord progressions) are part of the entirety of musical composition. And I thought that a band lyricist just generated the words.

How can a band have its lyricist credit himself with all the melodies?

How can a band’s lead singer come up with BOTH the lyrics and the melodies at the same time?

Isn’t musical composition considered a complete package consisting of melodies, harmonies, rhythms, riffs, and chord progressions?

If an entire band is credited with the musical composition, shouldn’t the whole band come up with all the melodies as well during the songwriting process?

Any professional songwriters here care to give some input?
Jericho-79
 
Posts: 8
Joined: 29 May 2014, 21:06
Country: United States of America
Has thanked: 0 time
Been thanked: 0 time

Does a band’s lyricist typically write melodies as well?


Sponsor
 

Re: Does a band’s lyricist typically write melodies as well?

Postby stiiiiiiive » 06 Jul 2014, 23:46

Jericho-79 wrote:I just discovered an underground band from my area that recently released an EP on indie record label. On that EP, I found something peculiar about the songwriting credits.

Oh come on. Here we go :)

Jericho-79 wrote:All the music is credited to the entire band, while all the lyrics AND all the melodies are credited to the band’s lead singer.

I thought that the creation of melodies (as well as harmonies, rhythms, riffs, and chord progressions) are part of the entirety of musical composition. And I thought that a band lyricist just generated the words.

How can a band have its lyricist credit himself with all the melodies?

Nowhere the word "lyricist"is written in what you provided as an excerpt of the credits. you are the one who called the guy lyricist and you are the one who thinks a lyricist cannot compose melodies and sing.

Jericho-79 wrote:How can a band’s lead singer come up with BOTH the lyrics and the melodies at the same time?

Easy, look: I'm in a band. I write lyrics. I sing them on the melodies I compose myself. Sometimes the riff is mine, sometimes it's my mate's. What's the problem? Can't a guy write lyrics and sign them? Can't a car be also a vehicle? Can't a cooker also play piano? Can't a bird also walk?
I don't know if I'm a propoer lyricist, as in professional, or if I just happen to write lyrics (or maybe my englsh is not fine enough to get a subtlety here...)

Jericho-79 wrote:Isn’t musical composition considered a complete package consisting of melodies, harmonies, rhythms, riffs, and chord progressions?

If an entire band is credited with the musical composition, shouldn’t the whole band come up with all the melodies as well during the songwriting process?

Any professional songwriters here care to give some input?


Well, I'm far to be professional in that I do not make money woth my music, but I think I have some experience now. I feel you're looking at it the wrong way: it's not "if a band is credited like this, should they do like that". It's more like "a band did that, and that is the way they credit themselves". Things happen. Words describe them as they can.
Minkovski FB
Toxic Overdrive Deezer
DNOT Deezer FB
User avatar
stiiiiiiive
 
Posts: 664
Joined: 14 Oct 2011, 15:07
Has thanked: 67 times
Been thanked: 132 times
Your Nord Gear #1: Nord Modular
Your Nord Gear #2: Nord Electro 4

Re: Does a band’s lyricist typically write melodies as well?

Postby RedLeo » 07 Jul 2014, 00:16

@stiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiive

I think he's trolling. if you look at all his posts, they're suspiciously similar.

"How can singer also write lyrics?"

"How can a keyboard also be a synthesiser?"

I mean, really?
Last edited by RedLeo on 07 Jul 2014, 00:20, edited 1 time in total.
RedLeo
Patch Creator
 
Posts: 1558
Joined: 07 Aug 2011, 02:08
Has thanked: 140 times
Been thanked: 702 times

Re: Does a band’s lyricist typically write melodies as well?

Postby Gustavo » 07 Jul 2014, 16:06

@red leo: Maybe he just wants to add some fervent discussion to the discussion board!

But to answer the question, yes and no. The lyricist can be part of the band and as such he could be making the melody. But the lyricist could also be someone who does not play in the band and basically that person just wrote a poem and the band makes a song to fit that poem.

Saludos,
Gustavo
Synths: Nord Stage 2 SW, Nord Lead 4R, Vintage Vibe 64 Active, Dave Smith Instruments Pro 2, Minimoog Voyager, Prophet 6, Korg Volcas
Stand: K&M Spider Pro and Hercules X Stands
Recording: Zoom UAC-8
Speakers: EV ELXP 112-P, Event Alp 5
User avatar
Gustavo
Patch Creator
 
Posts: 801
Joined: 05 Apr 2009, 18:00
Location: Monterrey, MX
Country: Mexico
Has thanked: 145 times
Been thanked: 167 times
Your Nord Gear #1: Nord Stage Classic
Your Nord Gear #2: Nord Stage 2

Re: Does a band’s lyricist typically write melodies as well?

Postby nsureit » 10 Aug 2015, 07:12

When we were kids in the 60s, we all thought Lennon wrote the lyrics and McCartney wrote the music. Nothing was farther from the truth. Each wrote lyrics and music equally. By agreement, they were credited for writing all the songs, whether one or the other participated or not.

Now, one can say Lennon wrote more sublime and esoteric lyrics, perhaps. :shifty:
User avatar
nsureit
Donator
 
Posts: 49
Joined: 16 Dec 2014, 04:32
Country: United States of America
Has thanked: 95 times
Been thanked: 8 times
Your Nord Gear #1: Nord Stage 2


Return to Off Topic / About this Forum



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 15 guests